How Modern Technology Can Transform Provider Directories

​In an era where consumers can instantly check Yelp reviews before choosing a taco spot and track a package from warehouse to doorstep, it’s baffling, and dangerous, that healthcare provider directories remain so riddled with errors. Yet, this has been the quiet, persistent crisis of the healthcare industry for years, and it’s finally boiling over.

Over the past few years, a series of lawsuits, federal and state reports, and eye-opening studies are spotlighting the serious consequences of inaccurate provider directories. From ghost networks to claim denials, to access barriers and compliance fines, the ripple effects aren’t just operational headaches, they impact patient lives and financial stability across the healthcare ecosystem.
​
Let’s unpack why this problem matters now more than ever, what’s driving the dysfunction, and what payers, providers, and policymakers need to do about it.

What’s Actually Going Wrong?
A provider directory is a basic, foundational tool meant to help consumers find in-network doctors, book appointments, and avoid surprise medical bills. But in far too many cases, that tool is broken.

According to the CMS, it's estimated that more than 55% of provider directories contain at least one critical error, whether it’s a wrong phone number, an outdated address, or a listing for a provider who’s retired, no longer accepts a given insurance, or isn’t even credentialed anymore.  Multiply that one bad phone call by the millions of Americans navigating care each year, and the fallout is enormous:

• Delayed care and unmet medical needs
• Denied or delayed claims
• Increased patient churn
• Burned-out call center staff
• Skyrocketing operational costs
• Regulatory penalties
• Damaged member trust

Ghost Networks: The Hidden Barrier to Care
One of the most harmful consequences of inaccurate directories is the phenomenon known as ghost networks, when insurers list providers who aren’t actually available to see patients. This practice gives the appearance of network adequacy on paper while leaving patients stranded when they try to schedule care. Not only do ghost networks obstruct access, but they also help insurers sidestep network adequacy penalties by inflating the appearance of provider availability.

As Dr. Jane Zhu of Oregon Health & Science University aptly put it, “We haven’t applied the same rigor to provider directories that we have to Yelp reviews or restaurant apps — and that’s ridiculous because network adequacy is a fundamental part of the patient experience.”

The Financial Toll: $2.1 Billion and Counting
The hidden costs of poor provider data management is substantial. According to the Council for Affordable Quality Healthcare (CAQH):

• $2.1 billion is wasted annually on provider directory inefficiencies
• Claim denial rates are 10–20% higher when provider data is incomplete or outdated
• 60% of directory updates are still handled manually, leaving the door wide open to error and delay
• CMS fines can hit up to $25,000 per beneficiary per day for directory violations

The result is operational chaos: lost appointments, frustrated members, denied claims, overworked staff, and millions in preventable expenses.

Value-Based Care Can’t Thrive on Bad Data
Inaccurate provider directories also threaten broader healthcare reform efforts. Value-based care models rely on accurate, timely data to steer patients to high-quality, cost-effective providers and manage total cost of care. When directories are wrong, value-based care initiatives stumble. For example, patients may be sent to out-of-network or unavailable providers, care coordination falls apart, costs balloon and more. 

A January 2025 report noted how flawed directories continue to frustrate value-based care efforts, undermining progress toward lower costs and better outcomes.

Time for the Industry to Move Forward
The technology to solve this issue is already here. Real-time data integration, AI-driven data validation, and digital self-service portals for providers have the power to revolutionize directory management. Progressive payers and data management firms are leading the charge, showing what’s possible when innovation is prioritized. The entire industry, however, has the opportunity to accelerate this transformation. It's not just about meeting compliance standards; it's about creating a future where accessible, affordable, and patient-centered care is a reality for all.
​
An inaccurate provider directory is no longer just an administrative challenge, it's a call to action with the potential for real, positive change for patients, payers, and providers alike. In 2025, we have the tools, such as PDAI, to ensure that a patient with an insurance card in hand has a clear, reliable path to the care they need. 

Learn more about Perspecta's Provider Directory Solution

DOWNLOAD